Slideshow image

Thomas Aquinas is one of the most important thinkers in history, especially when it comes to understanding the relationship between faith and reason. His Five Proofs for God’s existence continue to inspire debate, even though they were written in the 13th century. While many find his arguments helpful in explaining why God exists, others have raised questions and offered critiques. Let’s explore some more of these challenges and why Aquinas’ work still matters today.

Challenges to Aquinas’ Fifth Proof

Aquinas’ Fifth Proof argues that unintelligent things, like plants or planets, work toward a purpose or goal. For him, this shows that an intelligent being—God—must be directing them. But not everyone agrees. German philosopher Immanuel Kant had a lot to say about this. He argued that human minds naturally organize what we experience into patterns and laws. This doesn’t necessarily mean there’s an intelligent creator behind everything. Kant also pointed to the problems of evil, suffering, and contradictions in physics as reasons to doubt Aquinas’ idea of a grand designer.

Another criticism comes from atheists like George Smith, who think Aquinas’ way of dividing reality into “contingent” (things that depend on something else to exist) and “necessary” (things that exist on their own) is arbitrary. In other words, they think Aquinas just made these categories up without enough proof. But Thomists (people who defend Aquinas’ ideas) respond by saying these categories reflect what we see in the real world. For example, everything we observe is either in a state of potential (it could become something else) or actuality (it is already something). According to Thomists, this shows that at least one “necessary” being—God—must exist to keep everything else going.

Is Aquinas’ Science Outdated?

Some critics say that Aquinas’ arguments rely on outdated science from the Middle Ages, making them less relevant today. Philosopher Anthony Kenny, for example, argues that Aquinas’ view of the world was based on medieval ideas that we now know are wrong. However, Thomists counter this by saying that Aquinas’ scientific knowledge isn’t the main point of his arguments. His reasoning, especially in the cosmological argument (which says there must be a first cause for everything), still holds up even with modern science.

Why Aquinas Still Matters

Despite these critiques, Thomas Aquinas remains one of the most influential philosophers and theologians ever. His ability to blend the ideas of Aristotle with Christian beliefs created a new way to think about faith and reason. His Five Proofs give people a starting point to think about God, even if they don’t believe in the Bible.

Aquinas’ work continues to challenge and inspire thinkers today, not just in the Church but also in philosophy and science. While we might not agree with everything he wrote, his ideas encourage us to ask big questions: Why does anything exist? Does the universe have a purpose? And how can faith and reason work together? These questions are as relevant now as they were in Aquinas’ time, proving that his legacy is here to stay.